Are Book of Mormon Maps Misleading? The Problem with Internal Geography Models
By Christ in Peru | Featuring research and commentary by George Potter
What if some of the most popular maps of Book of Mormon lands are based on assumptions rather than historical evidence?
For generations, researchers and enthusiasts have attempted to identify the geographical locations of the civilizations described in the Book of Mormon.
From the forests of North America to the ancient cities of Mesoamerica and the dramatic landscapes of Peru, numerous theories have emerged.
Many of these theories rely heavily on what researchers call internal Book of Mormon maps.
But how reliable are these maps? And can they actually tell us where the Nephites and Jaredites lived?
In this episode of Discovering the Book of Mormon Through Science and Exploration, author and explorer George Potter examines these questions and challenges several widely used geographical assumptions.
What Are Internal Book of Mormon Maps?
Internal maps are geographical models constructed primarily from descriptions found within the Book of Mormon itself.
Researchers analyze references to rivers, mountains, wilderness areas, seas, cities, and travel routes to develop possible representations of ancient Nephite geography.
These models can be useful tools for visualizing geographical relationships within the narrative.
However, George Potter argues that an internally consistent map does not, by itself, establish the location of a historical civilization.
A map can illustrate a theory. It cannot independently prove that the theory is correct.
The Problem: Limited Geographic Information
One of Potter’s central arguments concerns the relatively limited amount of geographical information available in the Book of Mormon.
His presentation identifies six broad categories of clues:
- Lands described as northward and southward.
- References to exceedingly high mountains.
- Seas associated with different directions.
- Wilderness areas.
- A narrow neck of land and a narrow strip of wilderness.
- The River Sidon and its geographical relationships.
Although these descriptions contribute to the narrative’s internal geography, Potter argues that they are insufficient to construct a definitive map of the ancient Americas.
Different geographical regions may contain landscapes that resemble these descriptions.
Without additional evidence, several proposed locations may appear plausible.
Assumption #1: Did the River Sidon Flow North?
The River Sidon plays an important role in geographical discussions of the Book of Mormon.
Some proposed models assume that the river flowed north.
But does the text actually establish its overall direction?
George Potter points to Alma 2:15 and Alma 2:34, which provide geographical relationships involving the river.
He argues that these passages do not describe the entire course of the River Sidon.
Real rivers rarely follow a perfectly straight route. Their directions change according to the surrounding terrain.
Potter uses the Bear River in the western United States as an example of a river whose course changes direction significantly.
The central question is therefore straightforward:
Can researchers confidently assign a modern river to Sidon when its complete course is not specified in the text?
Assumption #2: Was Zarahemla Twelve Days from the City of Nephi?
Another common claim concerns the distance between the City of Nephi and Zarahemla.
Mosiah 24:25 describes Alma’s people arriving in the land of Zarahemla after spending twelve days in the wilderness.
However, Potter emphasizes two important distinctions.
First, the journey described in this passage does not establish a direct route beginning at the City of Nephi.
Second, the travelers arrived in the land of Zarahemla, rather than being specifically described as arriving at the city itself.
Without knowing the precise starting point, route, travel conditions, or destination within the region, the passage cannot establish a precise distance between the two cities.
Mountains, rivers, difficult terrain, and the composition of the traveling group could all have affected the journey.
Twelve days of travel does not automatically translate into a measurable distance on a modern map.
Assumption #3: Was Zarahemla at a Lower Elevation?
The Book of Mormon also describes people traveling down into the land of Zarahemla.
In Omni 1:13, the journey is described as passing through the wilderness before descending into the land.
Some geographical models interpret this language as establishing that Zarahemla was at a lower elevation than the City of Nephi.
Potter questions whether that conclusion can be drawn with certainty.
A descent from one point in the wilderness does not necessarily establish the elevation relationship between two distant cities.
Interpreting historical geography requires careful attention to the actual text and the assumptions introduced by modern readers.
The Difference Between a Map and Evidence
This brings us to the most important question in Potter’s presentation:
Where is the supporting evidence?
A proposed geographical model should be evaluated through multiple independent lines of investigation.
Archaeology may provide information about the dates, settlement patterns, technology, and material culture of ancient civilizations.
Historical records and indigenous traditions can offer additional perspectives, although they must also be interpreted critically.
Potter proposes examining questions such as:
- Were substantial cities present during the relevant periods?
- What evidence exists for metallurgy and ancient technology?
- What do archaeological discoveries reveal about agriculture, transportation, and trade?
- Are there records of writing systems or complex political organizations?
- What do local traditions reveal about ancient religious beliefs?
- Can independently dated archaeological findings support proposed geographical connections?
These questions highlight the importance of separating documented discoveries from speculative identifications.
Why George Potter Investigates Peru
George Potter has spent years exploring possible relationships between ancient Andean civilizations and the Book of Mormon.
His research considers archaeological sites, geographic features, cultural traditions, and historical accounts from Peru and neighboring regions.
He argues that these discoveries make the Andes a compelling region for additional investigation.
In particular, he sees the relationship between Peru’s ancient civilizations and several features described in the Book of Mormon as worthy of closer study.
However, similarity between an archaeological discovery and a scriptural description does not establish that the two are historically connected.
The identification of any specific ancient Peruvian site with a Book of Mormon location remains an unproven hypothesis.
Can We Really Map the Lands of the Book of Mormon?
Internal maps can help readers understand geographical relationships within the Book of Mormon narrative.
They can also provide starting points for research.
But a map becomes misleading when uncertain assumptions are treated as established facts.
George Potter’s central challenge is that researchers should begin with evidence and evaluate their assumptions rather than allow a preferred map to determine their conclusions.
This distinction is valuable regardless of which geographical model a researcher favors.
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints does not endorse any particular location for the Book of Mormon’s events beyond identifying the ancient Americas as their general setting.
Watch the Documentary: Book of Mormon Internal Maps
Join George Potter in this thought-provoking exploration of Book of Mormon geography, geographical assumptions, and the continuing search for historical evidence.
[EMBED YOUTUBE VIDEO HERE]
Explore Ancient Peru with Christ in Peru
At Christ in Peru, we invite curious travelers, history enthusiasts, and readers of the Book of Mormon to discover the remarkable cultural and archaeological heritage of Peru.
From ancient cities to extraordinary Andean landscapes, Peru offers countless opportunities for historical exploration and meaningful discovery.
Explore our research, documentaries, and upcoming educational tours at Christ in Peru.
This article presents George Potter’s research perspectives for educational discussion. Proposed geographical connections are interpretations and should not be understood as established archaeological conclusions or official Church positions.